Cloth Diaper Geek

Making cloth diapering mainstream

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Disclosure Statement
  • Advertising

Cloth Diapers vs. Disposable Diapers: The verdict, cloth IS less absorbent.

This post may contain affiliate links

…but isn't that a good thing?

So often with disposable manufacturers the issue of “maximum absorbency” is a big deal.  The big name sposie manufacturers go to great lengths and spend millions to develop a product that is built to soak it up, soak it in and absorb-absorb-absorb.  But in reality, is that something you really want or need?

Admittedly, the issue of absorbency is usually a great source of confusion with moms who switch from disposables to cloth.  They expect cloth diapers to work just the same as disposables and are often surprised when they don't.  When a cloth diaper doesn't make it through the night without leaking or a trip out to run errands, moms frequently and mistakenly think there must be something wrong with that diaper or brand.

Truth is that cloth diapers need to be changed more often than disposables, but that's not something that should be considered an awful inconvenience.  With disposables sure, the longer the baby can wear the diaper the less diapers you'll use and the more money you'll save.  But at what cost?

Putting yourself in your babies shoes, or let's say diaper…Would you want to sit in a wet, hot, gell filled diaper for hours on end just because it's not yet leaking?  Or as a toddler, would you want to be toddling around with a five pound bag of hot jelly swinging around between your legs when you've just learned to walk?  I think not.

Personally, I was happy to be a little inconvenienced by having more frequent diaper changes when I realized the alternative:  Letting baby sit in a soiled diaper just because I can.  It's a gross thought.

That's my two cents.  I feel the case for cloth is stacked against disposables for just this one simple fact, and I didn't even need to mention the health risks, chemical and carcinogen exposure associated with the use of disposables.

Julie

Julie

I'm Julie, a former cloth diaper retailer who discovered a passion for the industry. Now, instead of selling cloth diapers, I advocate them and promote small businesses I love who sell and manufacture them.

I'm the wife of a fireman and mother of three. I have a daughter and identical twin sons.

Share
Pin
Tweet
0 Shares

Related posts:

  1. Are your cloth diapers leaking? Here are some of the possible reasons why.
  2. Fish Tank Ammonia Remover, Is it the magic cure for your cloth diapers?
  3. 10 Reasons Your Cloth Diapers Might Be Leaking or Smelling (and how to fix them)
  4. Cloth Diaper Gossip: Shhhhh…Cloth Diapers aren’t supposed to be ugly.

Sponsor Love

Winner of the BeBeMellons Cloth Diaper Giveaway is…@Caedmen aka Rachel!
Sweet Pea Diapers Product Overview and Giveaway! Ends 10-06-11

Comments

  1. nikki says

    September 21, 2011 at 2:35 pm

    Yeah, those are my thoughts exactly. It took me a while to relaize that I needed to change my guy’s diaper more often with cloth. And he’s a super night soaker too. I have yet to find a diaper (cloth or disposable) that doesn’t leak at night.

    Reply
  2. MamaBear says

    September 21, 2011 at 3:20 pm

    I agree! Not sitting in chemicals is one of the main reasons I use cloth so even if disposibles are more absorbant I much prefer changing diapers more often. I also get great satisfaction from the fact that I’m not throwing money away at every diaper change.

    Reply
  3. Jena says

    September 21, 2011 at 4:09 pm

    I was just having this discussion with my husband yesterday, about how I’d rather change her diaper more frequently than saturation demanded it. And the thing about people trying to save money by leaving their kids in disposables longer between changes? Ew! Poor kids!

    My 8mo daughter has just started nightly over-saturating two inserts. I’m a person who’d really rather not get out of bed in the wee hours to change her diaper & PJs; it wouldn’t be so bad if she didn’t scream and thrash the whole time–it’s like she’s having a nightmare and it makes me feel awful, and I often can’t get back to sleep afterward. But I’ve heard good things about Knickernappies Super Do inserts, so I ordered a few & we’ll see how those work.

    Reply
  4. Anonymous says

    September 22, 2011 at 8:17 pm

    I don’t think I would ever use cloth diapers. I am already in survival mode and adding the extra changing and cleaning is not worth the ordeal. At some point you just have to say “do I really want to turn into a crazy helicopter parent?” I do anything and everything I can for my daughter – there are some really good disposable ‘eco’friendly diapers…

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sponsor Love

Kijani Baby
Cuddle Bear Bottoms
Tidy Tots
Lilly and Frank Ad
Diaper Lab

About Author

Jennifer Reinhardt

Jenn is a long-time cloth diaper educator and a passionate small business advocate. She has worked in the reusable diaper industry for over a decade, helping millions of families as well as hundreds of small businesses via her websites All About Cloth Diapers, Thinking About Cloth Diapers and Cloth Diaper Geek. Her goal always to provide simple, reliable information.

Popular Posts

#FluffinAwesome Baby Shower Food {Diaper Crescent Rolls}#FluffinAwesome Baby Shower Food {Diaper Crescent Rolls}
DIY: How to strip (clean) your washing machine!DIY: How to strip (clean) your washing machine!
Keeping Hermit Crabs ALIVE 101:  You can learn from my mistakeKeeping Hermit Crabs ALIVE 101: You can learn from my mistake
$349 One of a kind Diaper Bag Giveaway: Celebrating Mothers Every Day$349 One of a kind Diaper Bag Giveaway: Celebrating Mothers Every Day

Copyright © 2023 Cloth Diaper Geek All Rights Reserved