• Home
  • About Us
  • Disclosure Statement
  • Advertising

Cloth Diaper Geek

Blogging about cloth diapers and life.

  • cloth diaper 101
  • washing
  • cloth diaper reviews

Powder or Liquid Detergent for Cloth Diapers?

This post may contain affiliate links

You’re thinking to yourself, “Seriously?! I’ve decided to start using cloth diapers and now I have another decision to make on the kind of detergent I should use?! Why does it matter!!??” Great question and I was wondering the same thing too. Why does it matter if I use liquid or powder detergent?
The short explanation of it is that it’s really a preference thing; although some will argue with that statement. The theory in using liquid detergent is that it’s already in a liquid state so it is readily able to get into the down and dirty of the diapers and inserts that you’re washing. The downside of using liquid detergent? Most liquid detergents have additives to the solution that makes the gel substance stay together and not separate. The benefit to using powder is that it is generally cheaper and the cardboard box is also more eco friendly. Some people find that powder detergent doesn’t disolve well in their washer.That can lead to detergent build up, which, believe me is a stinky situation.
 
 
The only thing your REALLY need to stay away from when considering what detergent to use is if it has a synthetic fabric softener (for example Tide with Downy) That is the only type that you have to stay away from.
 
There is a ton of information out there on detergents from blog posts to charts. Here are a few of my favorites:
 
Padded Tush Stats Detergent Survey Results – Read frequently updated results based on cloth diaper users’ opinions. Very detailed with a number rating system.
If you do a Google search the myriads of results can be overwhelming so first figure out. Do some research and then use common sense and all you’ve learned to arrive at a solution that works for you and your family. Lastly don’t give up. After all, Rome wasn’t built in a day.

 

Elizabeth (aka Bert) is a stay-at-home-mom and contributing writer for She Thinks Media. She lives in the Twin Cities with her husband, Ben, her son Buggie, and daughter Lady Bug.  When she’s not trying to convince Buggie to expand his interests beyond Thomas the Train or put his pants back on she’s writing about her experiences as a mom on her blog, First Time Mom (FTM). After all, Bert maintains there’s a first time for everything, even if you  have more than one child! 

Share
Pin
Tweet
0 Shares

Sponsor Love

Sponsor Spotlight, Have you got the Inside Scoop? 8/20/2012
Cloth Diapers suitable for Lady GaGa’s baby?

Comments

  1. PGoBiren says

    August 28, 2012 at 2:03 pm

    We use powder. I’ve taken to mixing the powder in with the water in a jar quickly before pouring the mixture into the wash. I feel it helps with making sure the powder doesn’t get stuck on whichever diaper it happens to land on.

    Reply
  2. Xi Manco says

    September 27, 2012 at 6:16 am

    I’ll choose liquid detergent. Powder may leave some substance. That may harm the skin of the baby. Especially that they’re still sensitive.

    Reply
  3. Carolyn says

    January 30, 2014 at 11:57 am

    I’d also heard that powdered detergent has more water softening agents in it, which is why it tends to get better survey results with hard water users (though I have no idea where I’ve heard that, it just seems to be one of those things everyone says ….) But in any case, it is why I stick with the powder ;)

    Reply
  4. FUTURECLOTHDIAPERQUEEN says

    April 20, 2017 at 11:42 pm

    STINKY ISSUES COME UP for people who buy into the cloth diaper safe detergents- because cloth diaper company/so called cloth diaper safe detergents don’t get diapers clean at all. Enzymes and baby oxygen clean or using bacout is not going to destroy your diapers nor make it function less. We are dealing with poop and urine- and Tide Free and Clear Powder, Ultra Tide Powder and Gain Powder are awesome detergents for cloth diapers. Rock in Green, Country Save, Laundry tarts, Nellies, other liquid detergents gave my friend’s diapers the stinkies and Nellies made the colours fade out and would only work out if you used their oxygen bleach- Nellies alone would leave diapers stinky. My friend and I live in hard water parts and Powder Calgon has just be discontinued where we live- not sold online nor available in stores in our country. The detergent that has the most water softeners is the TIDE POWDER detergent.

    I’d rather see a diaper wear out sooner, fade sooner , but be always nice and clean on the inside and not cause ammonia burns or stinkies then a diaper that looks like new on the outside but is stained and smells of urine on the inside the most important part- which makes contact with the baby’s bum. The baby could care less if the sunshine or flower designs on the outside of the diaper are faded or not- what makes contact with the skin is the most important.

    I understand babies have allergies- I myself am allergic to SUNLIGHT detergent- but if Tide Free and Clear Powder or Ultra tide powder does not give your babies allergies nor cause smelly diapers I say go for it. And nothing wrong with soaking inserts or flats in oxyclean free or oxy clean baby or adding colour safe/chlorine free bleach to your laundry cycle a couple times a month. Another alternative to getting rid of dingy washes and restoring diapers to their original state is RLR(CADIE).

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Hey there!

I'm Jenn and I am PROUD to be the new caretaker of this amazing resource. I have found a passion not only in educating about cloth diapers but also being a strong supporter of small business. Thank you for joining me on this journey!




julie, cloth diaper geek blogI'm Julie, a former cloth diaper retailer who discovered a passion for the industry. Now, instead of selling cloth diapers, I advocate them and promote small businesses I love who sell and manufacture them. I'm the wife of a fireman and mother of three. I have a 15yr old daughter and identical twin sons who are 12yrs old.


becca,cloth diaper geek I'm Rebecca and I'm a wife, mother, and work at home mom. I enjoy things like babywearing, cloth diapering, breast feeding, and using all natural solutions in my house. I teach Spanish to my children and their friends and I also love to sing, play the guitar, paint, draw, read, crochet, knit, and sew. Most importantly, I love Jesus and I strive to follow his example.

Categories

  • accessories
  • all-in-one cloth diapers
  • ammonia issues
  • babywearing
  • cheap cloth diapering
  • cloth diaper 101
  • cloth diaper reviews
  • cloth diaper tips
  • detergents
  • diaper covers
  • DIY
  • eco-friendly product reviews
  • onesize cloth diapers
  • potty training
  • reusable menstrual products
  • Uncategorized
  • washing

Copyright © 2021 Cloth Diaper Geek All Rights Reserved